Here are some reasonable things that should be added to Madden 2008.

1) Ability to return missed FGs that are short, i.e. Devin Hester.
2) Have offensive playbooks more specific, for example how the Jags like to line up with Matt Jones at QB or the Jets with Brad Smith, make it a formation sub.
3) Being able to actually return a punt.
4) Import/export players from AFL and NFL Europe
5) Ability to lateral on a kickoff for some last minute despiration and/or to run a hook and ladder, etc.
6) More creative special teams play, fakes (eventhough I don't run them), laterals as mentioned, and reverses or throwbacks, ability to block kicks.
7) Get rid of the Tony Bruno show, it's annoying.

That's my wishlist.