[SlickRick1382]

Manning becuase of what Italian said (by the way i don't like your neon name) and also because I said so. That being said, Manning wins.....j/k... Its obvious that Manning possesses an ability very few even can even claim. I mean what he did to that Bucs D last year, despite how bad they played the whole year they did have a big lead going into the 4th. And although Manning has some good targets, I think some of that can be accredited to the fact that he spots them when they're open and gets them the ball with such accuracy. He gets the ball to everyone on his team. That game that i referred to like 3 different recievers made an important 3rd down catch. Like 3 & 15 and it was Reggie Wayne or whatever and no Harrison that got the ball. Other than Marvin Harrison i don't know if you can consider anyone else a playmaker on that team (james is always hurt) but their good because he makes them look good. If he had a D that can back him up, well then forget about it.