Well I could end this discussion right now, because Barry Bonds is better than both of them.... he has won MVP 6 times....but and I am just curious here, but sense someone keeps bringing up Emmit Smith all the time I have to ask this.... Say Barry played in dallas in those years... and emmit played in Detroit, and dallas never won a championship, but Detriot won three, and for some odd reason Barry Sanders ended up with the career rushing title, would you still feel as strongly about Emmit??? And I want you to really think before you answer....